Treaty and Talks
Diplomacy

Israeli Election Deadlock Sparks Coalition Scramble

Israel's election has produced a political deadlock with no bloc securing a majority, setting up a complex period of coalition negotiations.

Israel's election has produced a political deadlock with no bloc securing a majority, setting up a complex period of...

Israel's election has resulted in a political deadlock with no clear path to a majority government.

Voter turnout was high, with 77.7% of voters casting ballots, the highest rate since 1999. Eisenkot's Yashar party is projected to win around 22 seats, with his broader change bloc reaching about 47 seats. Israel's Arab parties are collectively projected to win at least 17 seats.

Coalition possibilities and constraints

Three scenarios now dominate the political landscape. The first is the formation of a unity government. The second is another round of elections, which would see Netanyahu remain as interim prime minister. A similar sequence of events played out after the 2019 election, culminating in a vote in March 2021. The November 2022 election then returned Netanyahu to power.

The third scenario is a minority government formed by the change bloc with the backing of Arab parties. Combined, they could command up to 65 seats. This path is fraught with difficulty. Tolerance for working with an Islamist party has diminished since the deadly Hamas-led raids of October 7, 2023. Also, the change bloc parties stated unequivocally during their campaigns that they would not form a government with either of the Arab parties. This stance persists despite the precedent set from 2021 to 2022, when Mansour Abbas, leader of the Islamist Ra’am faction, broke a long-standing taboo by joining a centrist coalition.

Expert analysis and public sentiment

Experts highlight the profound challenges of breaking the impasse. Political scientist Gideon Rahat of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem noted the shifting political landscape, suggesting past norms may no longer apply. Professor Jonathan Rynhold said it was possible that Eisenkot could put pressure on his potential ally, Avigdor Lieberman, to accept a minority government.

Public sentiment appears deeply skeptical of such an arrangement. Yohanan Plesner, president of the Israel Democracy Institute, observed the significant political and public hurdles. "It’s obviously not only a violation of campaign promises," he said, "but I think the Israeli public opinion is deeply unprepared for such an option."

The path forward

The formal process for government formation is set to begin next week. President Isaac Herzog will hold consultations with each party before deciding whom to task with building a coalition. Herzog must choose whether to offer the mandate first to Netanyahu or to Eisenkot. Analysts suggest Netanyahu may prefer to lead a caretaker government, refuse compromises, and take his chances in a new election in about six months.

Former US ambassador to Israel Daniel Shapiro, now a distinguished fellow with the Scowcroft Middle East Security Initiative, is among the observers watching the unfolding situation. Another distinguished fellow at the same initiative, former US diplomat Gina Abercrombie-Winstanley, also brings a perspective on the regional implications. The question of who Israel's next prime minister will be remains entirely uncertain, pending the President's decision.

Related coverage

More from Diplomacy