Treaty and Talks
Relationships

Trump's Concessions to Russia Undermine Ukraine Ahead of Abu Dhabi Talks

As US-Russia-Ukraine talks convene in Abu Dhabi, President Trump's policy shifts have eased pressure on Moscow while Putin offers no substantive concessions, widening the gap in peace efforts.

As US-Russia-Ukraine talks convene in Abu Dhabi, President Trump's policy shifts have eased pressure on Moscow while...

The Trump administration has made multiple concessions to Russia that ease Moscow's aggression and complicate Ukraine's defense. Over recent weeks, these steps have included finalizing a deal to resume Russian diesel shipments in violation of US sanctions policy, waiving sanctions from a recently passed bill, turning off intelligence provided to Ukraine via Starlink and Starshield systems, and entertaining Putin's proposal for a three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping. The Kremlin greeted all these concessions with great enthusiasm. President Donald Trump's stated objective is to establish a stable peace where Ukraine is sovereign and secure, and since spring 2025 he has offered at least a half dozen proposals to end the fighting. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has agreed to each of Trump's proposals. These peace offerings sparked strenuous bipartisan criticism in Congress.

Putin's rejection and procedural response

Russian President Vladimir Putin has deflected or rejected all of Trump's proposals, including the most recent one brought by US Special Envoy Steve Witkoff in Saint Petersburg in October. Putin has not offered a single concession of his own that could lead to a stable peace. His objective in Ukraine is establishing effective political control over the country, and his principal method is undermining Western and especially American support for Ukraine. In turning down Witkoff, Putin offered a procedural accommodation: Russia agreed to a trilateral working-level meeting in Abu Dhabi. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov announced that "Moscow would offer no new concessions; its terms for 'peace' would not change."

Abu Dhabi talks preparation and limited expectations

Negotiators from Russia, Ukraine and the US will meet in Abu Dhabi next week for the first time in months. US Special Envoy Steve Witkoff announced the trilateral talks on ending the Russia-Ukraine war will take place on 10-11 November. Any realistic expectations for the upcoming Abu Dhabi talks should therefore be very modest. The talks are only taking place because Putin wants to give Trump a reason to continue to distance himself from Ukraine. The Kremlin named former Russian Minister of Culture Vladimir Medinsky as the head of its delegation; he has been involved in most talks with Ukraine since March 2022. Last winter's talks in Abu Dhabi involved intelligence and defense officials discussing technical aspects of troop dispositions for a ceasefire.

Zelenskyy's stance on direct talks and ceasefire

President Zelenskyy dismisses direct talks with Putin and insists a ceasefire is the essential first step toward peace. He said inviting Putin to Moscow is 'spitting in the face' of everyone who wants peace. Zelenskyy stated he sees no point in a phone conversation with Putin and that Ukraine is not inviting him to Kyiv. He wants real steps toward peace rather than listening to history lectures. Zelenskyy stated the first step toward ending the war is a ceasefire, adding that a ceasefire could happen without a meeting if Russia wanted it to. Following a conversation between Putin and certain European leaders, Zelenskyy said Russia appears serious about meeting with negotiating teams in Abu Dhabi.

Security architecture and NATO's role

In the wake of Putin’s rejection of the latest peace proposal, Team Trump chose to focus the Abu Dhabi talks on a new security architecture for Europe. The administration announced it had put together an approach that all sides could accept, which includes a major role for NATO in providing security. Witkoff and fellow special envoy Jared Kushner stopped in Brussels to go over the plan with Ukraine and the Europeans ahead of a meeting on security guarantees for Ukraine. Moscow's demands directly contradict this vision. Yuri Ushakov, Putin’s foreign policy adviser, delivered the message that "Moscow believes that a new security system requires the former Warsaw Pact and Baltic states to withdraw from NATO." The Kremlin has shown the same unwillingness to negotiate seriously on this front. The upcoming talks in Abu Dhabi are expected to yield only procedural outcomes rather than substantive steps toward peace.

Related coverage

More from Relationships