Treaty and Talks
News

Pro-Israel Money Drove Haley Stevens' Party Switch

Michigan Rep. Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers after losing the Democratic Senate primary, a move fueled by over $30 million in pro-Israel super PAC spending that first backed her against Abdul El-Sayed.

Michigan Rep. Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers after losing the Democratic Senate primary, a move fueled by...

Haley Stevens, a Democratic congresswoman from Michigan, narrowly lost her party's Senate primary to Abdul El-Sayed in August. Her subsequent endorsement of Republican candidate Mike Rogers was driven by more than $30 million in spending from pro-Israel super PACs, which first boosted her campaign before shifting support to the GOP in the general election. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer called her endorsement a 'despicable betrayal'.

The Michigan Democratic Senate primary was exceedingly expensive, with most funding going to support Haley Stevens against Abdul El-Sayed. Much of this funding came from out of state and outside the Democratic Party, unified by pro-Israel megadonors' desire to boost Stevens. Nearly three-quarters of Democratic voters oppose providing additional economic and military support to Israel. Stevens, who is not Jewish, once said 'I see Israel in my dreams' and emerged as the model staunchly pro-Israel candidate for Israel's lobby.

El-Sayed's stance and the ad controversy

Abdul El-Sayed openly criticized Israel and U.S. aid instrumental in Israel's war on Palestinians in Gaza, which numerous leading human rights groups have deemed a genocide. An independent group backing El-Sayed, Rebellion PAC, released an advertisement linking US military aid to Israel to Americans' struggles with the cost of living. It showed a couple putting back eggs to save money for 'killing Palestinians'. Stevens called the advertisement anti-Semitic and demanded El-Sayed condemn it. El-Sayed said the advertisement was not produced by his campaign and that he disagreed with its message.

Stevens' party switch and its fallout

Rep. Haley Stevens abandoned the Democratic Party and endorsed Mike Rogers, the Republican Senate candidate in Michigan. Effectively switching parties within 48 days of a consequential election is not normal behavior. Stevens had previously attacked Rogers as a 'rubber stamp for Donald Trump's dangerous agenda' and emphasized her commitment to a Democrat winning the Michigan Senate race. She told reporters she was endorsing Rogers because 'We can't stand with hate. We can't stand with Hasan Piker,' referencing El-Sayed's association with political streamer Hasan Piker.

Stevens accused El-Sayed of making 'some' anti-Semitic actions during his campaign. She insisted she was still a Democrat and planned to vote for Democratic candidates in 90 percent of races on her ballot, but her Senate vote would go to Rogers. The Democratic National Committee issued a blistering statement calling Stevens' decision a 'betrayal of the values of the Democratic Party'. Michigan Democratic Party Chair Curtis Hertel said Stevens had 'abandoned everything she claims to care about'.

Stevens's chief of staff for eight years, Justin German, and several other staff members stepped down over the endorsement. Stevens and El-Sayed were supposed to attend a church service together in a show of Democratic unity, but Congresswoman Debbie Dingell said she asked Stevens not to attend, calling it 'way too distracting'.

The money and the lobby

Speculation about Stevens' behavior centered on her fiancé, but political journalism suggests following the money is the primary driver. Israel's lobby backed Rogers in the general election after failing to influence the Democratic primary. Rogers' campaign is staffed by individuals doing contract work to spread pro-Israel messaging; his campaign spokesperson Abby Ronson and communications staffer Jesse Stokes are both registered agents for the state of Israel. Schumer explained to The New York Times last year that 'My job is to keep the left pro-Israel'.

Schumer and other senior Democrats were silent as millions of dollars poured in from out-of-state and out-of-party sources to attack El-Sayed. In most cases, pro-Israel ads avoided any mention of Israel, a tacit admission their core issue was toxic with Democratic voters. Nancy Pelosi attacked El-Sayed and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's criticisms of Israel as 'wrong and not a reflection of the Democrats in the Congress'.

Israel's lobby has spent nearly a quarter-of-a-billion dollars on this election alone. Its core mission is preventing the transmission of public opinion into public policy. A trio of organizations representing Jewish, Muslim and Democratic voters called on House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries to 'expel' Stevens from the Democratic caucus. Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal supports taking action against Stevens.

El-Sayed and Rogers are competing to replace retiring Democratic Senator Gary Peters in a closely contested race that could help determine which party controls the US Senate. Early voting began on October 24, before the latest dispute erupted. Once Stevens leaves office in January, her endorsement will likely cast a long-term shadow if she chooses to remain in politics. Hertel wrote that Stevens 'is not a current member of the Michigan Democratic Party, nor will she be in the future'.

Topics

#News

Related coverage

More from News